15 Hours of Talks. No Deal. Continuing Sunday.
15 Hours of Talks. No Deal. Continuing Sunday.
Vance and Ghalibaf sat across from each other for 15 hours in Islamabad — the highest-level U.S.-Iran face-to-face since 1979. Iran's delegation wore black. Journalists waited at a convention center with tea and musicians. And at 4 AM local time, the White House said: "15 hours and counting." Here is what we know.
The talks were supposed to last one day. They went through three rounds of negotiations, stretched past midnight, continued into Sunday morning, and ended without a deal — or a breakdown. Iran's government posted: "Negotiations will continue despite some remaining differences." A senior White House official texted reporters: "15 hours and counting!"
The fact that both sides are still talking is significant. The fact that neither side has announced a deal — or walked out — tells you something about the gap that remains.
What Each Side Said
The Public Statements While Talks RanWhat's Actually Happening Inside
What Leaked OutPakistani sources told CNN the overall tone remained "largely positive" — but a stalemate persists over the Strait of Hormuz. A source close to Iran's negotiating team told CNN the U.S. made "unacceptable demands" over the strait and several other issues. Al Jazeera sources said "some progress" was made on Lebanon — specifically, reports of a possible understanding to limit Israeli strikes to southern Lebanon rather than all of Lebanon. There were also signals of "some movement" on unfreezing Iranian assets.
Iran's 71-member delegation — the size and seniority of which experts said signaled genuine intent — was led by parliament speaker Ghalibaf and included Foreign Minister Araghchi, along with political, security and economic officials. The Iranian team arrived wearing black, carrying shoes and bags of students killed in U.S. strikes. The symbolism was deliberate.
The Sticking Points
Where the Gap RemainsThree issues dominate. Hormuz: The U.S. wants complete, immediate reopening. Iran wants to maintain "full sovereignty" and charge per-ship fees. U.S. destroyers began mine-clearing operations Saturday — while talks were still ongoing — signaling America's intention to open the strait with or without a deal. Lebanon: Iran says any deal must include a halt to Israeli strikes on Hezbollah. Vance said Lebanon is "not up for discussion in Islamabad." Some movement was reported — possibly limiting strikes to southern Lebanon — but no agreement. Frozen assets: Iran wants unconditional release. The U.S. has signaled "some movement" but no commitment.
📊 The Qatar Signal: While talks ran, Qatar's Ministry of Transport announced maritime navigation would "fully resume for all types of vessels" in the Persian Gulf starting Sunday morning. This is not the same as Hormuz reopening — Qatar controls its own territorial waters. But it is a signal that Gulf states are moving to normalize trade before any formal agreement. The economic pressure that made the ceasefire possible is also, slowly, beginning to ease — which reduces some of Iran's leverage at the table.
Day one of the Islamabad talks produced no deal — and no collapse. Both sides are still at the table on Sunday, which is itself a form of progress in a war that nearly ended with a "civilization dies" post on Truth Social five days ago. The stalemate is real. The gap on Hormuz, Lebanon and frozen assets is real. But 15 hours of direct U.S.-Iran engagement — the most since 1979 — also represents something that did not exist a week ago. Whether Sunday produces a deal, a framework, or a breakdown is the only question that matters today.
Comments
Post a Comment