Israel and Lebanon Have a Ceasefire. Hezbollah Still Won't Disarm.
Israel and Lebanon Have a Ceasefire. Hezbollah Still Won't Disarm.
Trump announced a 10-day Israel-Lebanon ceasefire Thursday. Hezbollah said it would abide by it — if Israel stops. But Hezbollah's senior legislator made clear that disarmament is not on the table. Israel's stated goal is exactly that. Here is what each actor wants, what each will accept, and why 10 days from now this problem will still be unsolved.
A ceasefire between Israel and Lebanon is not the same as a peace agreement between Israel and Hezbollah. That distinction matters enormously in the next ten days. The ceasefire buys time — for Iran talks, for diplomacy, for the hundreds of thousands of displaced Lebanese to breathe. But the structural conflict underneath it has not moved an inch.
Hezbollah's senior legislator Ibrahim al-Moussawi said it clearly within hours of the ceasefire announcement: the group's weapons are non-negotiable except "within a framework tied to a broader national security vision." Israel's PM Netanyahu said just as clearly: Israeli forces will stay in Lebanon's security zone and Hezbollah must be dismantled. Two irreconcilable positions, ten days to bridge them.
What Each Actor Wants — and Will Accept
The Four-Way Map📊 The 1701 Problem — Already Failed Once: UN Security Council Resolution 1701, passed after the 2006 Lebanon war, required Hezbollah to disarm south of the Litani River and the Lebanese army to deploy there. Eighteen years later, neither happened. Hezbollah is larger and better-armed than in 2006. The Lebanese army never enforced the resolution. Israel is now demanding the same thing 1701 demanded — and getting the same answer. The ten-day ceasefire gives everyone a pause. It does not give anyone a mechanism to achieve what 18 years of UN resolutions could not. When it expires, the same forces will be in the same positions, pointing the same weapons at each other.
The 10-day ceasefire is real and valuable — it stops the killing, removes Iran's biggest stated obstacle to a nuclear deal, and gives Lebanese civilians a pause from the most intensive bombing since the war began. But it does not resolve the underlying conflict. Hezbollah will not disarm. Israel will not leave without disarmament. Lebanon's government cannot enforce either. Iran will not pressure Hezbollah to give up its weapons. In ten days, the ceasefire either extends — requiring another negotiation that hits the same walls — or it collapses, and Israel resumes bombing Lebanon, Iran cites it as a U.S. violation, and the nuclear deal falls apart before it can be signed.
Comments
Post a Comment